book2book

  booktrade.info

Search Booktrade.info:  


Monday 13th February

Book2book Home Book Trade News Trade Announcements Bestseller Lists About Booktrade.info

Writers Should Comply With Schools Vetting, Says Children's Laureate

Posted at 9:27PM Thursday 16 Jul 2009

New children's laureate Anthony Browne has attempted to calm the storm that has blown up among children's authors over a new scheme requiring them to be vetted before visiting schools.

Philip Pullman described the vetting scheme as "outrageous, demeaning and insulting" to the Guardian on Friday and said he wouldn't be appearing in schools again because of it.

Browne, however, has taken a more sanguine approach to news of the scheme. "I feel that as writers we shouldn't necessarily be granted an exemption," he said. "If all people who work with children have to be vetted by the police then we shouldn't be an exception."

Anthony Browne in The Times

More in The Guardian

Comments

I'm sorry that Anthony Browne does not seem to agree with Philip Pullman's views on the new vetting scheme. Why is it that today that all adults' interactions with children are viewed with suspicion by "the authorities"?

Philip Pullman states that he is not a paedophile but "the authorities" vetting procedures seem to assume that a man who writes books for childen and is happy to admit that he enjoys the company of children, is, at least, a little suspect.

This is the outrageous aspect of the whole issue of the measures "the authorities" are now taking over child protection.

I am a father of three grown up children and about to be a grandfather for the first time. Recently, I was in the front garden when I heard a noise in the street and then a scream. I ran out to find a young girl of about 11, tangled up with her bicycle on the footpath with scrubbed knees and elbows, sobbing.

I hesitated, she obviously needed help but, because "the authorities" and their "thought police", the tabloid media, had over the years made me question my own motives regarding my interaction with children, I wondered how my actions might be viewed.

It only took a second for my "normal" human reaction to kick in. I picked her up and tried to comfort her. Luckily my wife was in the house, so I told the girl that she would be able to help. The girl, still sobbing let me take her into the kitchen, where my wife, cleaned her cuts. We gave her a drink and I put her bicycle in my car and took her home. Her parents were very grateful that we had helped their child.

I believe that if we allow "the authorities" to continue alienating adults from the world of children, our children could be placed in more danger. How many adults already think twice about approaching children, even if they think a child might be in difficulties?

The Jamie Bolger case highlighted the fact that many adults had seen the child in obvious distress, but decided to do nothing.

I do not blame "the authorities" for this. The blame should be with the Anthony Brownes of our society, who seem to assume that "the authorities" know best.

Our children need to be protected from paedophiles, whose crimes are abborent to all "normal" people. Paedophiles may look like "normal" people but why do "the authorities" pursue policies that suggest that all "normal" people might be out to harm our children.

Philip Pullman is not asking for authors to be a special case. He is merely highlighting the very disturbing trend that, according to "the authorities", we are all potential paedophiles.

When "the authorities" get their way and have vetted the 12 million people who have any contact with children and "encouraged" the 50 million other citizens not to have any contact with children, will our children be safer? I do not think so.

Posted by Alan Twiddle <alantwiddle@yahoo.co.uk> at 12:14PM Saturday 18 Jul 2009
Offensive? Unsuitable? Spam? Report this comment.


Post a comment

Sorry, you need to be logged in to your Booktrade.info user account in order to post a comment - please log in and try again, or if you don't have an account sign up now - it's free! Once you're logged in you can choose how - or if - you want to be identified with your posting.




Get book trade news by email

Daily book trade headlines and breaking publishing news by email - just £3 a month. Click on the Subscribe button below to sign up now

Find out more


Search the news archive:
 







More Book Trade News

Cairo International Book Fair Awards
english.ahram.org.eg

General Egyptian Book Organisation wins majority of Cairo International Book Fair awards

Eason Plans 150 Job Cuts To Achieve €5m Saving
www.irishtimes.com

Eason has reached agreement with staff on a cost reduction programme that will involve about 150 voluntary redundancies

Working at a Big-Six (US) Publishing House
www.digitalbookworld.com

Culture, Pay, Advancement and Getting In

Hay-on-Wye gears up for an uncivil war
www.telegraph.co.uk

Plans for a supermarket are dividing residents – and splitting families – in the idyllic literary town

Ben Okri 'disappointment' at editor who claims re-wrote his work
www.telegraph.co.uk

Ben Okri, the Booker Prize winning author, has accused his editor of "exaggerating his own importance" after he claimed to have rewritten some of the writer's work

In Amanda Knox Tale, A Delicate Bet For Publishers
www.nytimes.com

Her personal charm aside, however, Ms. Knox's story is complex, disturbing and still hotly debated

Account Sign-In

Most Popular Stories

  1. British Children Are Culture Starved
  2. Ben Okri 'disappointment' at editor who claims re-wrote his work
  3. First-Ever Academy Awards (Book) Contest
  4. S*** Agents And Editors Say
  5. Critic Says Irish President's Poems Are A 'Crime Against Literature'
  6. James Joyce Children's Book Sparks Feud
  7. New Independent Publisher Based In Newcastle Upon Tyne
  8. Why Penguin Terminated Its Contract With Overdrive
  9. Judging Books By Their Covers: USA vs UK
  10. Dublin History Book Costs The Republic's Government £800 For Each Copy Sold